The Ethics of Storytelling in Nonprofits: Why It Matters & How to Get It Right
Storytelling is at the heart of nonprofit work. It’s how we connect with donors, inspire volunteers, and bring attention to urgent social issues. But here’s the problem: not all storytelling is ethical.
Too often, nonprofits fall into the trap of "poverty porn"—using exaggerated, exploitative, or dehumanizing narratives to evoke pity and drive donations. While this approach might work in the short term, it comes at a steep ethical cost.
So, how can nonprofits tell impactful, authentic stories while respecting the dignity of the people they serve?
What Is Ethical Storytelling?
Ethical storytelling is the practice of sharing real, respectful, and consent-driven narratives that empower individuals rather than reducing them to their struggles. It’s about telling the whole story, not just the parts that generate sympathy.
💡 A key question to ask before sharing a story:
"If this was my story, would I feel comfortable with how it’s being told?"
The 3 Core Principles of Ethical Storytelling
🔹 1. Empower, Don’t Exploit
People should be the heroes of their own stories. Instead of portraying them as helpless victims, focus on their resilience, agency, and strengths.
✅ Do this: Show individuals actively working toward solutions, making progress, or overcoming obstacles.
❌ Avoid this: Using images or language that strip people of their dignity just to evoke pity.
🔹 2. Prioritize Truth Over Sensationalism
It’s tempting to amplify struggles to make stories more dramatic, but honest storytelling builds trust.
✅ Do this: Share realistic, nuanced stories that reflect real challenges and triumphs.
❌ Avoid this: Exaggerating details or cherry-picking facts to create a more emotional response.
🔹 3. Respect Privacy and Consent
No story should be told without explicit consent from the individuals involved. This means:
Clearly explaining how their story will be used
Allowing them to review and approve the final version
Respecting their decision if they choose not to share
✅ Do this: Use quotes, names, and images only when given full permission.
❌ Avoid this: Telling stories on behalf of individuals without their consent.
The Long-Term Benefits of Ethical Storytelling
Choosing ethical storytelling doesn’t just protect the dignity of those you serve—it also:
✔️ Builds trust with donors and supporters
✔️ Strengthens your organization’s reputation
✔️ Creates more meaningful connections with your audience
Final Thought: Start With Intentionality
If you’re a nonprofit leader, marketer, or fundraiser, take a moment to audit your current stories. Ask yourself:
Are we representing people with dignity?
Have we obtained full consent?
Are we telling a truthful, complete story?
By committing to ethical storytelling, nonprofits can create real impact without exploitation—and that’s a story worth telling.
💬 What are your thoughts on ethical storytelling? Reply and let’s discuss!
👉 Subscribe for more insights on nonprofit storytelling & impact-driven communications.